Monday, March 25, 2024

The Warsaw Protocol

The Warsaw Protocol (Cotton Malone, #15)The Warsaw Protocol by Steve Berry
My rating: 2 of 5 stars

First book I read written by this author and I think the last.
Mostly I should blame myself, simply I am not interested with stories where in every second chapter someone is killed.
Other fault on my side is that I have difficulty to concentrate on very complicated and messy plot, specifically when the plot doesn't make much sense to me.
The only reason I gave it 2 stars were details about Polish history. I was amazed how many of them are included in the book and wonder how interesting they were for non-Polish readers - I am Polish.
Another point...
The plot of the book does not make any sense to me.
The idea is that presidential election in Poland is coming and president learns that a file of discrediting him information is to be sold for the highest bidder.
There is not a word of clarification of actual political situation in Poland - who is a possible contender in the election, what are main political parties, which of them is supporting the president.
There is an elaborate description of evolution of political situation in Poland after the Second World War and it looks that result in NIL. All power is in hands of a single person, so even worse than in the communist system.
Some logic.  

View all my reviews

Friday, March 22, 2024

Visit at The Magic Mountain

 I was lucky with Thomas Mann because I didn't start my relationship with him from The Buddenbrooks. My mother recommended The Magic Mountain to me, I found it in the library at the student residence and it enchanted me.

When I think about the details, I see many weak points in The Magic Mountain, but it seems to me that a person in love sometimes likes to find small flaws in the object of his affections.

The protagonist of the novel comes to visit his cousin who is staying in a tuberculosis sanatorium in Davos.
He comes for 3 weeks. In the sanatorium, he discovers the charm of freedom that illness gives – a loosening of morals, a lack of sense of responsibility.
He also discovers the memory of his youthful anxiety, which here takes the form of a green-eyed Russian woman and which causes him a low-grade fever typical of this place.

What is the effect and what is the cause?
It does not matter, the important thing is that he does not want to be cured of it. He willingly accepts the offer to extend his stay to 7 weeks in order to undergo medical observation.
Before he knows it, 7 months of this morbid condition have passed.
It is not until February 29 1908, a day that is also a quirk of the calendar, that he dares to speak intimately to the object of his feelings.
The next morning, his beloved leaves. It is not known where, it is not known whether she will ever return.

Our patients always come back here in the end – states the head doctor of the sanatorium – Councillor Behrens. And Hans Castorp remains.
The stay lasts a total of 7 years. This passion of Thomas Mann for numbers extended the book beyond the limits of patience.

I waited even longer.
In 2003, six times 7 years after the start of the spell, I went on a pilgrimage to The Magic Mountain. The pretext was another ski marathon. Instead of starting from Hamburg, like Hans Castorp, I started from Okęcie Airport in Warsaw.

It was Ash Wednesday. Waiting at the airport, I watched a TV news report – on the screen, Polish cardinal sprinkled ashes on the heads of the faithful.
Three days earlier, I had heard the gospel about how Jesus explained why the apostles did not observe fasting – when they were close to me, they did not have to fast.

In 2 hours I was in Zurich. Sunny. There was a food fair at the train station. It smelled beer and sausages
"Could it be that the Swiss are closer to God?" I thought.

Instead of going straight to Davos, I was heading towards St Moritz for Engadine Ski Marathon...


Next day after the race I took the train to Davos. The route led downhill, which struck me as very funny because it destroyed all the pathos of the phrase often repeated in the book: ...up there on the mountain.
I got off, like Hans Castorp, in Davos-Dorf…

After getting off the train I looked around – "…they turned left across the track, crossed the river…"
 – that made no sense at all, because then they would have ended up on the northern slope of the mountain, where the sun doesn’t reach, and therefore there are no sanatoriums.

After checking into the youth hotel, I went straight to the Waldhotel Bellevue - Sanatorium Berghoff. A steep walk up in Buolstrasse.
"…our sanatorium, as you can see, is even higher than this town – Joachim continued. – Fifty meters higher. The brochure says one hundred, but in reality it is only fifty…"

The lady at the reception was prepared for such visits and first sold me the book Thomas Mann and Davos, and then directed me to a corridor where there were hotel memorabilia from 90 years ago; at the end a room with original furnishings:
"... a white metal bed, a sink with nickel-plated taps... an American woman died here the day before yesterday, of course everything was thoroughly disinfected.".
There was a surprise though - a chamber pot! Thomas Mann omitted this detail in his novel. He also did not mention a bathroom. Right - there was none.

At the hotel I looked through the newly acquired book and burst out laughing on the first pages.  Thomas Mann deliberately changed the topography of Davos to prevent gossip and unhealthy sensationalism around existing facilities. So my surprise at the station was explained.

Davos itself – a typical ski resort, only maybe a bit bigger and with a lot of normal residential buildings and of course the congress centre, where the World Economic Forum and many other international meetings are held, but that is not part of this story.

People? Lots of young people with skis and snowboards. Unpretentious crowd. I found a note on the internet that the nightlife in Davos is not very exciting.

And what about those… “Englishmen with white teeth, heavily perfumed ladies, Americans with small heads… a rather suspicious crowd”?
If I met them anywhere, it was not in Davos, but at the Kempinski Hotel in St Moritz.
I spent the next day downhill skiing, but I did not bother to find the trail where Hans had his strange dream.

On the last day I returned to the Berghoff, sorry to the Waldhotel Bellevue. I found the Hohe Promenade and set off for a walk in the footsteps of the characters in the book.

The path was wide enough for three people, so Hans Castorp and Mr Settembrini and Mr Naphta walked side by side, and I walked a little behind. Listening to their discussion, I didn’t notice until we reached the Schatzalp Hotel…


"The highest located sanatorium is Schatzalp, there, on the other side, you can't see it from here. They must be shipping their bodies on bobsleighs, because the roads are covered".

Another piece of evidence confirming the author's deliberate distortion of the topography. Schatzalp is on the same slope as Waldohtel Bellevue. It must be there, because only this slope faces south.

Instead of a bobsleigh track, I found Bobbahnstrasse and a toboggan run that no one has used for a long time...


On the way back I visited the cemetery but didn’t find any of the names mentioned in the book…


Two hours later I was going down, this time on the “correct route” via Lanquart to Zurich. 

Since then I have often recalled this visit.
Its dry description does not sound very interesting. But I was not disappointed.
And now? The enchantment has lasted over 9 times 7 years.
Another year has begun, so it is a perfect time to remember how:
"It was the middle of summer. An ordinary young man was driving from Hamburg, his hometown, to the spa town of Davos in the canton of Graubunden…"

Thursday, March 14, 2024

The Cellist of Dachau

The Cellist of DachauThe Cellist of Dachau by Martin Goodman
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

My highest rating for a book in many years.
Amazing book confirming a saying - music starts where the words end.
Of course there are words, 318 pages of them but for most of the book they are very discreet, transcendenting words, music, life, feelings, emotions - impossible to be expressed in other words.
Story line... not just one, few - all of them connecting Holocaust victims and music.

Of course everything comes to the end, here I experienced disappointment - in the last few chapters the author confronts two key characters and tries to explain all what was unclear and mysterious throughout the book. In my opinion it is a failure.
Second thoughts...
Over one week since fished reading - still thinking about connecting in the book quite contradicting story lines. Final conclusion was surprising - Rose - granddaughter of Adiutant of Dachau concentration camp is in some way also a granddaughter of Otto - victim of Holocaust. I do not know if it was authors intention, but I suppose he could expect such conclusions.
View all my reviews

Saturday, March 9, 2024

Roseanne

Roseanna (Martin Beck, #1)Roseanna by Maj Sjöwall
My rating: 1 of 5 stars

The book bored me terribly - some mysterious crime and then snapshots of actions or rather waiting of inspector Beck.
Lot of names of police inspectors and names of cities they visit to find any tracks of the crime.
I understand that it may be a honest picture how really looks work of police inspector, but there are so many professions, I am not able to get familiar with all of them.
Additionally there are many mentions about inspector's Beck family life and these are really depressing.
I have to confess that I skipped some 60 pages to eventually learn about the outcome of the investigation.
I consider it wasted time.

View all my reviews

Friday, March 8, 2024

The Pole

The PoleThe Pole by J.M. Coetzee
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

Beatriz, middle aged, Spanish, attractive woman with a solidly established family is asked to take care for a Polish pianist visiting Barcelona for concert of Chopin's music.
The concert doesn't make a good impression on her, the pianist, almost 25 years her senior - even worse.
Still, almost against her own will, she got entangled in a web of his dreams.
What struck me most is the fact that all very intimate thoughts and feeling of Beatriz are described in detail by the man.
It happened that the 3 last books I read were written by women and I am sure that they could not be written credibly by men.
So I have to treat this book as a sort of sweet dream of old man.
On the other hand I appreciate the language and style of J.M. Coetzee writing and this I liked regardless of the story.
P.S. Interesting point is that the book has been originally written in English but was first published in Spanish translation by an Argentinian publisher.
J.M. Coetzee explained that he wanted to break domination of Northern hemisphere over the book market.
Privilege of rich and famous.  

View all my reviews